Showing posts with label european history. Show all posts
Showing posts with label european history. Show all posts

Friday, February 01, 2008

Stand Alone Complex

I've recently come across the idea that the Christian laws against incest were put in place in order to stop the practice of rich families marrying internally (see post below). Families would do this in order to keep their fortunes, dowries and inheritances within the family, rather than see their heightened economic status slowly dissipate into the surrounding general society. Perhaps they also had some interest in keeping the growth of the family down to a minimal level, so that each share of the fortune was kept large.


The church's was they found that, with restrictions against incest in place, more money would flow to the church itself. As the families broke down over generations, loyalties to immediate groups like clans and caste diminished in favour of a sense of belonging to larger groups; like the state and the church. In other words, through this mechanism, was a long-term attack against one of the church's competing centres of power.

Apparently, this idea is put forward in J. Goody's The Development of the Family and Marriage in Europe, and Deepak Lal's Unintended Consequences. In the meantime, I'm so taken by the concept, and so willing to see it slip, oh so smoothly and cleanly, into my personal mythos of man, that I'm almost willing to believe it on pure principle. Unintended consequences, indeed.

In the news today, the two suicide bombers in iraq, who have been reported my many sources as having blown themselves up in crowded markets, killing many people, didn't actually do that. Apparently, in truth, someone else blew them up--by remote control.

Presumedly they knew what was strapped around them; but, as they wandered around the crowd, keeping to the middle of the most dense areas and battering between people, they must have been thinking: when is it going to happen? Meanwhile, whoever it was that bundled them up in explosives and told them that this would redeem them from whatever dreadful sin caused them to be punished with their mental illness; whoever it was that claimed providence over death, picked their preferred time and place, and lived to do it again.

UPDATE: it turns out the reporting around the above described incident was error prone and unreliable. And so, the above two paragraphs are hereby pronounced Completely Invalid!

Wednesday, December 19, 2007

"I felt like destroying something beautiful"


A couple of military leaders from recent history have caught my attention and interest lately. General Tito (mentioned below) of Yugoslavia, and one Mustafa Kemal, otherwise known by the epithet “The Father of the Turks,” Ataturk.


Ataturk was the bane of the Ottoman empire. He brought sovereignty to the people of Turkey, ending the Caliphate and causing the last Ottoman rulers to exile themselves to England. And so the first world war claimed its only major world power casualty; this despite the fact that the crippled empire desperately wanted to remain neutral and fought only one significant battle—one battle that it conclusively won.


Ataturk is very fondly remembered in Turkey, even today. He was, by all accounts, a man larger than life; and now larger than his own mortality it seems. I've heard him described as a man out of his own time, a throw back to glorious old days and legends of conquerors; perhaps something like Alexander the Great, the young Macedonian who marched over Turkey and is also fondly remembered for his benevolence. Ataturk was born of the same stuff as those awe inspiring legends; because Ataturk was born in battle, in glory and guts and passion, in the moment of his most remembered command, in victory on the beaches. This is how the Ottomans lost the war: they made Mustafa Kemal into Ataturk, the man who could order an entire division to die, and a nation to live.


One brings with it the other, don't you see? The ancient Greeks knew it. The Turks knew it, also. They wouldn't trust so greatly as to follow him into revolution. But for this man, tens of thousands had followed his man's outstretched pointing hand and traded their lives for a few seconds of diversion on the battlefield. He was to be trusted; and believed; and followed.


And he revolutionised them. Wear hats, he said, write like an Englishman, we are modern men now! And so the new president and the new nation took on the image of those who had once been so close, within easy throwing distance in the next trench. It was Ataturk who brought the sides together after the war; he decreed that the fallen from both sides would be accepted into the Turkish bosom and receive the great respect of the locals. Perhaps he understood that both sides hadn't really being fighting each other; in fact, in may ways, they were all fighting side by side, for the one and same goal.


The ancient Greeks understood this, also. This was the same region as their greatest, most remembered and most import war, after all. This is were the subjects of millions of reliefs, sculptures and paintings had arisen. This was the birth place of the Hellenistic identity, where the Adonis ideal arose. This was where ten thousand black ships arrived, under a weak pretence for war, to find for themselves the greatest and longest lived glory in history. They held siege for 9 years, fighting as the opportunity arose, and waiting for the moment when noble and skilful opponent would stand and reckon them, and they would engage in one on one combat to the death. The stories were passed around with greatest reverence for centuries before Homer could collect them up. And even today, the siege of Troy is recognised as special moment of history, a profound singularity.


In the First World War, the Great War, Hellen wasn't a beautiful woman, however. She was Russia, and the pretence was to open the straights for her supply shipments. And yet, there were no Russians fighting there, just confused troupers, like the Indian Muslims who heard the call for prayer and wondered, who are we fighting?


And yet, the allies found something there, also, in that mythical land. They didn't fight with against their enemy, they fought with their, soon to be glorious, enemy. Because there is a belief that great nations are born in war, a belief that would seem evident from history. There is something that flows from war, something otherwise unattainable. It made the nonconformist Kemal into Ataturk, it made the Mycenaeans, the Minoans and the Cycladeans into Greeks, by way of shared heritage. But what did it make of the wanderlust Australians and New Zealanders who suffered from the lack of a war back home?

Thursday, December 13, 2007

The Antikythera Mechanism


This is a 500 billion Yugosalv Dinar note. 500 billion of of the poor little buggers. How did such an extraordinary thing come to exist? Well, it's certaintly didn't involve Bill Gates immigrating.

It turns out, during an uncertain part of General Tito's state, the currency went through an inflation rate of 5 × 1015 percent per month (prices double every 16 hours). To me, that seems facinating--because it seems more like an abstract mathematical or distant astronomical oddity. But it's not. It was a real phenonomen arising from a real, practical, human oriented system. This was hardly a one-off event, either. We saw and studied many occurances of hyperinflation during the 20th century.

More details here.

Picture courtesy of the National Bank of Serbia. By the way, current Serbian Dinars are far more reasonably valued.